[Ted and Barney discuss the GNB headquarters project, which may involve tearing down the classic Arcadian theater]
Ted, I know you love classic stuff no one cares about, but I'm gonna give you four words to live by: New Is Always Better.
Ted
New is always better?
Ted, you know who's a million times hotter than the hottest girl I've ever slept with? Her okay-looking friend I haven't seen naked. Why? Because new is always better.
[Ted and Barney discuss the GNB headquarters project, which may involve tearing down the classic Arcadian theater]
Ted, I know you love classic stuff no one cares about, but I'm gonna give you four words to live by: New Is Always Better.
Ted
New is always better?
Ted, you know who's a million times hotter than the hottest girl I've ever slept with? Her okay-looking friend I haven't seen naked. Why? Because new is always better.
Ted
And this theory applies to everything?
Ted
So, those new Star Wars movies... Those are better than the old ones?
Yeah. The first three barely mention the intricacies of intergalactic trade law.
Ted Mosby
And when you're at a Guns N' Roses concert, you're like, "yeah, yeah, Paradise City, whatever. When are they gonna rock me some Chinese Democracy"?
Axl's really matured as a songwriter, Ted.
[Ted consults Lily about what to do with his students after they walk out, thanks to Zoey. Lily described what she did to Johnny Marley]
Ted
Lily. You're a psychopath.
Little bit. [to student who gave her a panda drawing] Ah, a panda!
FTFuture Ted
I thought about Lily's advice, and I figured, fear was worth a try. [Ted walks to picket line]
Well, Professor Mosby, is there anything you want to say to us?
Ted
[to students] Anyone not in class tomorrow gets an F. [students are shocked]
[at MacLaren's]
FTFuture Ted
Well, technically they'd get an "Incomplete," but I thought "F" had a nice, scary ring to it.
[Barney quotes the sign-off phrases of multiple reality TV shows, when telling Ted that he needs to tell Punchy to leave.]
You are the weakest link, Goodbye. Punchy, the tribe has spoken. Please pack up your knives and go. Your work of art didn't work for us. Your time's up! I have to ask you to leave the mansion. You must leave the chateau. Your tour ends here. You've been chopped.
Ted
OK, yeah I know...
You've been evicted from the Big Brother house. Your dessert just didn't measure up. Sashay away. Give me your jacket and leave Hell's Kitchen. I'm sorry, you did not get a rose. You have been eliminated from the race. You are no longer in the running to be America's Next Top Model. You're fired. Auf Wiedersehen.
Ted
Lily, do you have any idea how many people I blindly hated for you?! I hated Renée Zellweger with a burning passion for eight years only to discover you meant Reese Witherspoon!
Hey! I will hate her until I will get my money back for You, Me and Dupree!
Ted
THAT'S KATE HUDSON!
Oh yeah...That's who I hate. [to the others] Guys, we hate Kate Hudson.
The Blitz isn't something that can be bought or sold.
Yeah, it's not like Ted's integrity.
Ted
Oh, what was that? I was distracted by the four-karat diamond your 53-year-old husband bought you.
Ted
Now, if you'll excuse me, I have a turturkeykey to baste.
Ted
No…I baste alone.
Oh, I'm sure you're a master baster, Ted.
Ted
Hey guys, Zoey just told me about this great Frank Lloyd Wright retrospective, who's in?
Sorry, I'm ummmm...I don't know, washing my hair.
I'll be home trying to get over the fact that no one invited me to the big hair washing party.
[Ted meets The Captain on his boat]
Ted
Where's Zoey?
Well, I'm afraid she's feeling under the weather. Guess it's just you, me, and six hours in frigid international waters.
Ted
Or we could stay in dry land, hang out with some witnesses?
[Ted has just smashed his gingerbread house because Marshall said that after the pregnancy false alarm, he and Lily want a dog]
Ted
[to Marshall and Lily] Are you kidding me?!? All you ever talk about is having kids, and now you have one little freakout, you want to get a dog instead? No, unacceptable! You're gonna turn around, go home, get naked, lie together as man and wife until Lily is great with child! Right now. [couple still look at him] I'M SERIOUS, GO GO GO!
[after seeing the two leave, murmuring to Robin] Marshall and Lily got in trouble...
Ted
And YOU! Barney, you look real stupid in that suit. You're gonna get your money back and give it to charity - and I don't mean that stripper you keep emailing us about even though we begged you to take us off that list.
I can't give this suit back. Ted, I glow in the dark. I finally glow in the dark.
Ted
[shouts] Criminals of New York, attention! This man is wearing a diamond-encrusted suit, you could retire on the pants alone. Merry Christmas! [Barney runs away and Ted confronts Robin]
So if I get a large popcorn, would you go split-ski -
Ted
And you, you did not move into the greatest city on Earth to become a coin-flipping bimbo. [takes out coin] So, here's how it goes - Heads, you take the job at Worldwide News. Tails, you take the job at Worldwide News. [flips coin into Robin's face] Hey, looks like somebody got a new gig!
[Barney explains the origins of Desperation Day]
Loneliness...the looming specter of Valentine's Day fast approaching...the two key ingredients to my favorite day of the year - February 13th, Desperation Day.
It's a thing. Much like Valentine's Day itself, Desperation Day dates back thousands of years. [Visualizes Roman-era wedding] Weddings were forbidden under ancient Roman law, so St. Valentine performed them in secret, under threat of death.
Ted
That's actually true.
Ted
This won't be.
And right by St. Valentine's side was his best bro, St. Desperatius, there to pick off insecure bridesmaids.
[Cut to fantasy scene with Barney as St. Desperatius and Ted as St. Valentine. Desperatius sees woman who looks like Robin.]
[Lily has had enough of Marshall being cooped up in the Eriksen house since the funeral, and Ted's presence does not help.]
Marshall, I'm going home.
[pauses from game session with Ted, comes to Lily] What?
I'm flying out tonight before the big storm, and I want you to come with me.
I can't right now, 'cause my mom needs me.
Well, I guess it's been helpful for her for you to be here playing Super Mario Kart for 14 hours a day...
Ted
[surprised] You have Super Mario Kart!?
Hell, yeah. [points to cartridge. Ted gets it and loads into the SNES]
...but your mom doesn't need you. Your life in New York needs you, it needs you really bad.
[kisses Marshall and leaves] Please come home soon.
Oh man, this movie is scary.
STScoundrel Ted
I know, right?
I don't know who he is, but I pictured him with a mustache.
Ted
Limit the search to guys with mustaches. Smart.
Anyway, soon the inevitable happened. She told me she was in love with someone else. Obviously, it made me angry.
Ted
And the, that was the last time you saw her...
...but I gathered my composure and told her I'd do anything to keep her. I begged her not to leave. We made love that night -
Ted
[spits out drink] It's damned good brandy.
[Ted, Marshall and Lily alert Robin that Scooby's missing from the apartment]
Ted
Robin! Hey, remember Scooby? Well, he got out.
Got out? What do you mean?
Ted
He just walked right out of the apartment. Someone must've left the door open.
Me neither. [gasps] He must have figured out how to open it himself!
Ted
He's so smart, we should get him on Letterman doing tricks!
I know Paul Schaefer's sandwich guy. This can happen.