[Reverend Lowell has had enough of the false stories of how Barney and Robin met and ordered them out, until Barney speaks his mind]
You know what? We shouldn't have lied about our story. I love our story. Sure, it's messy, but it's the story that got us here, about to get married.
Robin
I love it too, every messy chapter. I love that you slept with over 250 women before deciding that I was your favorite.
RLReverend Lowell
This is killing me.
And I love that we just had to keep on having sex with each other even when we were dating other people.
LLowell
This is really killing me.
Robin
And I love that your marriage proposal involved a strip club, lying to me, and pretending to bang the woman I hate for two months.
I love that we keep a running tally of all the different rooms we had sex in.
Robin
And I love that two weeks ago, we put [looks at reverend] this room on that list.
Ha? Come on Rev, that's gotta be worth some kind of a reaction, right? I mean, right where your hymnal is where we.. where we.. [notices blank stare; Barney gets closer and sees the Reverend is dead; to Robin] Well, that's not what you want.
[Robin gets ready for her own scrambled eggs]
Robin
Okay, scrambled eggs. Here we go, where is the egg opener? [Barney and Lily shake heads] Never mind I'll prescramble them. [shakes eggs as Barney and Lily are still shaking heads] OK, fine Loretta. You know what, you win. I don't know how to cook egg.
If you don't even know how to make scrambled eggs, I just worry what kind of breakfast you're gonna be serving my grandchildren.
Robin
[choking up] Oh, well, lucky you, because that is one thing you will never have to worry about. [leaves]
Mom, Robin can't have kids.
[Barney braces for Marshall's Slap of a Million Exploding Suns, and Robin is afraid.]
Robin
I love you.
Enough to take this slap for me?
Robin
[sadly] No. [goes behind Marshall]
[Ted admits that he broke up with Victoria because of Robin, who wants to know the truth]
I'm not gonna answer the question, because you know the answer. You want to talk about my Top Five? There's no Top Five, Robin, there's just a Top One - and it's you. And the only reason I'm saying it is, 'cuz I know it's not gonna change anything. You and Barney are getting married today. If I have to hold the shotgun myself, it's happening.
Robin
I thought you don't like guns.
I'm the best man. I swore on the Bro Code. I don't want to go to Bro Hell.
Robin
Bro Hell sounds bad.
I'm sure Barney's got a whole thing about Bro Hell.
Robin
But... What about when we get back from our honeymoon? What about our first night out at the bar, what then? Is it gonna be weird?
Robin
How can you be so sure?
Because I'm not gonna be there. I'm moving to Chicago.
[Lily just turned off the TV as Robin is watching The Wedding Bride Too]
Robin
Did you just turn off the bride's TV on her wedding day?
Oh oh, is this your wedding day? I'm sorry! Couldn't tell, because you're acting like its any other Sunday morning, and it's not!
Robin
Lily, if you're waiting for me to suddenly turn into the wedding bride, you just give up, that's not me.
Fine, maybe we should just act like this wedding's no big deal, and you know what? I don't feel like wearing my bridesmaid's dress.
Robin
Great, it's just a wedding. Who cares what people wear?
[shows Barney another suit in a different room] SAY YES TO THIS SUIT!!!
[crying] I can't. I can't! [Ted throws suit on to the floor]
[Marshall talks to Lily after discovering her positive pregnancy test]
Lily... you're gonna have a baby?
[pause, teary-eyed] I told you guys I could keep a secret. [embraces Marshall]
Robin
Uh Barney, this is my mom.
GSGenevieve Scherbatsky
Hello - [shakes Barney's hand but startled at embrace] Oh! He's a hugger. Nothing like your dad.
[to Marshall] I'm sorry, I was gonna tell you tonight -
No, oh my God no that's fine. There’s so much we have to do. We have to do research on, uh, hospitals in Italy. We have to -
We’re not going to Italy.
Of course we are. Lily, we have to do this. You’re going to live in Rome. And you’re going to get your dream, 'cause you’re giving me mine — again.
But there's gonna be all sorts of paperwork - and if she's born outside of the US, she could never become President!
Oh I don't know, but in my mind, I kinda think she is!
I love you so much. [embraces Lily]
[Robin's mother tries to comfort her daughter]
GSGenevieve Scherbatsky
Oh darling, you're going to be fine. You know for every marriage in the world like I had with your dad, there's a marriage like [points to Marshall and Lily inside the bride's room] those two in there. Marriage is terrifying. It's like flying, you know - you're filled with a mortal dread, but if you find someone you feel safe with, it's like, flying! But if you got someone that is really there for you, someone you can depend on, you're gonna be fine. Do you have someone like that?
Robin
[contemplates] I do.
[Robin calls Ted on letting Barney take credit for finding her locket, and thinks she should go to Chicago with Ted]
Stop, stop! You're saying this because you're scared! I am not your future. Barney is.
Robin
Shouldn't I be with a guy who finds me my locket? The guy who steals me the blue French horn? I mean look me in the eye and tell me why shouldn't I be with that guy?
Because I'm not that guy anymore.
Robin
Then why did you work so hard to find me my locket?
Robin
Ted stop it, okay? I've known you better than that. This is more than a wedding gift.
Maybe it started out that way. Maybe some part of me thought—
Robin
—that you still loved me.
Maybe, but the truth is…I don't love you like that anymore, and you don't love me. You love Barney, and if you think I would ever be part of screwing that up, then maybe you don't know me at all, Robin.
Robin
Oh, I can't shake it, I can't shake this feeling that nothing about me and Barney makes any sense!
But love doesn't make sense! I mean, you can't logic your way in or out of it. Love is totally nonsensical. But we have to keep doing it, or else we're lost, and love is dead, and humanity should just pack it in. Because love is the best thing we do. Look, I know that sounds cheesy, but it's just true. You love Barney, and he loves you. And that doesn't have to make sense…to make sense.