Hughie
[leaving a message for Annie] Hey, Annie, it's me again. I was just wondering, have you ever seen the music video for that Billy Joel song "You're Only Human"? There's this kid and he's climbing up a bridge and he's gonna kill himself, but then Billy Joel steps out with his harmonica and tells him, "Stop, you just have to wait for your second wind". And now, I feel like I'm–I'm that kid… and I'm gonna drown, and... and thank God I found my second wind because it's–it's you. [tearfully] You're my second wind. Um... Look, I know it's exciting taking down Vought and being like James Bond and everything… but you've gotta be careful, because that stuff can go to shit really quick. And you wind up hurting the people that... you love. Like the way that I hurt you. Um... Anyhoo, that's all I wanted to say. Second wind. Um… Okay, thanks. Bye.
RWRobin Ward
This is like when we started dating.
HCHughie Campbell
I don’t think that’s–I don’t think that’s true.
RRobin
Dude, I had to ask you out.
Hughie
Well, excuse me for waiting. Ever hear of chivalry?
RRobin
Listen, this is about getting what you deserve. I’m killing myself at school because I think it’s gonna be worth it for both of us… You know, if we move in together.
Hughie
Wait, what? Wait… [stutters] Hey, what was that? What’d you just say?
RRobin
Well, I mean, we can’t keep laying pipe at your dad’s place, trying to be all quiet, staring up at that dumb Billy Joel… [Hughie kisses her] poster.
Hughie
Hey, don’t you ever besmirch Billy Jo–
[Robin suddenly disappears. Wind blows and blood splashes on Hughie’s face in slow motion. Hughie then looks to his right and sees A-Train panicking and covered in blood.]
[quickly] I can’t stop. I can’t stop, I can’t stop, I can’t stop, I can’t stop! I can't stop! [runs off]
Hughie
[pause] Robin?
[Hughie looks down and realizes he’s still holding Robin’s hands, but only her forearms remain]
Hughie
Robin… Robin?! ROBIN!
[Hughie is working at the video store late at night and sees a man holding a nanny cam teddy bear]
Hughie
You interested in a nanny cam? 'Cause we're actually running a special on that. Um, it's a pretty popular bear. There's cameras in the eyes.
BBBilly Butcher
Tell me, how many nannies shake their babies?
Hughie
Uh, I'm sorry?
Y'know, a good hard shake. [shakes the bear] Like… Like tryin' to get ketchup out of a bottle. One percent? Less?
Hughie
I–I don't really know.
[puts the bear down] Funny, that. They sell a billion dollars worth of that shit worldwide. Goes to show you, doesn't it? The bollocks people will believe if you get 'em scared enough.
Hughie
Cool. Cool, cool. Um, is there anything I can help you with today, or...?
I'm not gonna piss you about, Hughie. I heard what happened to Robin.
Hughie
I'm–I'm sorry, who are you?
She wasn't in the street. She was one step off the fuckin' curb, and you didn't take the payoff.
Hughie
Yeah. I said, who the hell are you? How do you know that?
Name's Butcher. Billy Butcher. [takes out an FBI badge] Listen, I was thinkin' that, uh, you and me should have a little bit of a chat.
[Cut to Hughie and Butcher walking down a street in downtown Manhattan]
Hughie
You’re a Fed? You don’t sound like a Fed.
What, I can’t immigrate? There’s a giant green slapper with her arse in the harbour that says different.
Hughie
You don’t really look like one either.
Hughie
Like you’re starring in a porn version of The Matrix.
Well, it’s all right there in black and white.
Hughie
Okay, uh, what exactly can I do for you?
No, you got it all wrong, Hughie. It's what I can do for you. You see, you ain't alone, son. Happens a lot more than you think. Supes lose hundreds of people each year to collateral damage.
Hughie
No. C'mon, that would be all over the news. People would be screaming bloody murder.
Yeah, look, there might be the odd mention of it every now and again, like with Robin, but there's a shit sight more that happens that just gets swept right under the rug.
Hughie
...Why?
Ain't it obvious? Movie tickets, merchandising, theme parks, video games. A multi-billion dollar global industry supported by corporate lobbyists and politicians on both sides. But the main reason that you won't hear about it... is because the public don't wanna know about it. See, people love that cozy feeling that Supes give 'em. Some golden cunt to swoop outta the sky and save the day, so you don't gotta do it yourself. But if you knew half the shit they get up to... Ooh. Fuckin' diabolical. But that... is where I come in.
Hughie
Come in to... to do what?
Spank the bastards when they get outta line.
[Annie is sitting on a park bench and on the verge of tears after a phone call with her mother. Hughie is sitting a few feet away when he notices her.]
Hughie
Um, excuse me. I’m sorry, are–are you okay? [Annie looks at him] Just seemed like a tough call. [pause; Annie doesn’t say anything] Sorry. I don’t mean to bother you.
ASAnnie/Starlight
No. No, it’s okay. Uh… I’m fine. I’m just… I’m just having a bad day.
Hughie
Yeah, me too. Is it like a work thing or a life thing?
ASAnnie/Starlight
It’s a work thing. You?
Hughie
Uh, life thing.
ASAnnie/Starlight
You know how you have this image of yourself? Like, I thought I was strong, you know? Like, made of steel. A fighter. And then, I was faced with this horrible situation with this asshole, and… I just heard my mom’s voice in my head: “Keep smiling. The show must go on.” And I didn’t fight. And now, I just feel sick. Partly because I did it, but mostly because… it turns out I’m not who I thought I was. [beat] Oh! Oh, I’m… sorry. I–I didn’t mean to just dump all of that onto you.
Hughie
No, no, it’s totally fine that you dumped. Um, listen, do–do you like your job?
ASAnnie/Starlight
Oh, it’s the only thing I’ve ever wanted.
Hughie
And it’s a good job? Like, you’re not selling kids smack?
ASAnnie/Starlight
No, it’s a great job. I could help a lot of people.
Hughie
Thing is, I… used to know this girl, and we used to go skating at Rockefeller, and I'd be on the side with this death grip on the rails. She would just charge headfirst into the middle of the rink. And she wasn't… good. Like, she fell… a lot, but she was never scared. And she always used to say, “Just 'cause you fall on your ass doesn't mean you have to stay there.” So you fell on your ass, you know? That's not who you are. So who are you?
ASAnnie/Starlight
[pause; smiles and shrugs] I’m a fighter. I’m gonna fight. Yeah, I’m gonna take that son of a bitch’s head clean off his body.
Hughie
Okay. Wow, that was… Okay. Cool. Little scary, but–but cool. [brief pause] I’m–I’m Hughie, by the way.
ASAnnie/Starlight
Annie. [shakes Hughie’s hand]
[Butcher and Hughie are parked outside Vought Tower to carry out their plan]
There's fuck-all security to worry about. In fact, they're a bunch of Muppets. [holds up bug] And the metal detector won't pick this up. Right? And what they'll probably do is take you through the security, and then up into the boardroom. Sit down. Be nice, congenial. Then, real polite-like, tell 'em you're gonna take a fake shit. Go into the bog, take the bug out. Peel back the plastic bit to reveal the sticky side. Put the plastic bit in the bog. Flush it. Then, go back into the boardroom, sit down–big smiles–plant the bug underneath the table. Easy-peasy Japanesey. Bob's your uncle. That's that.
Hughie
That's that? That was–That was a lot! That–Hold on, can you just–Can you repeat it again? Just a little bit slower? Because I–
Hughie
[deeply exhales] Fuck.
Hughie, calm down, alright? This is like that scene in The Matrix. Now, you could take the fuckin' red pill, right? Spend the rest of your life jackin' off, cryin' into your chai tea green latte, what the fuck. Or you could take the blue pill. Or is it the red pill? Anyway, take the other pill and quit bein' a cunt.
Hughie
Which pill do you want me to take?
Just quit bein' a cunt. That's what I'm sayin'.
[Butcher brings his associate, Frenchie, along with Hughie to an abandoned restaurant, where they imprison Translucent]
What d'you think, Frenchie?
You just dropped the Moby fucking Dick of problems on my plate. That's what I think, okay? He can re-order the carbon on his skin into metamaterial. It's hard as diamonds. It's nearly impossible to penetrate.
Alright, how 'bout we suffocate him?
Some Dominicans already tried this, way back in '07.
They're all fucking dead. That's what happened.
Alright, then, fuck it. Electrocution. We'll just increase the amps.
You already hit him with enough to drop a water buffalo, and look. Might knock him out. Doesn't seem to kill him, huh? No. We need to pierce the skin somehow.
Well, how the hell are we gonna do that?
Hughie
You're gonna kill him?
[pause; turns and stares at Hughie] We didn't bring him here for a fuckin' Happy Meal.
Hughie
I don't–I thought we'd question him or something. I don't know, you get a–you get a hold of someone this big–
At Gitmo, we had to waterboard Khalid Sheikh Mohammed 183 times over six months to get him to talk just once. Now, we ain't got six months. I doubt we've even got six hours.
Hughie
There are so many crazy things about what you just said. But right now, you're talking about randomly killing one of the most famous men on the planet. A goddamn national treasure. I mean… people tend to notice that kinda thing.
And if we let him go, what do you think The Seven will do to us? Hmm? You can't get A-Train if you're a greasy smear on the pavement.
Hughie
I'm not a murderer.
[Hughie brings a glass of water to the room where an invisible Translucent is caged]
Hughie
Hi. I thought you might be thirsty, so…
[He sets the glass down on the floor and opens a grate on the cage. Translucent doesn't react.]
Hughie
Well, if you don't want it, I can always–
[Translucent picks up the glass and drinks from it]
Hughie
So listen, I need to ask you some questions about A-Train. When he burst through that woman the other day–Robin Ward. I–I need to know why. Where was he going? What was he doing?
Why? What was she to you? Sister? Girlfriend? [pause; Hughie says nothing] Girlfriend. [sighs] That's what all this is about? Christ. What makes you think I know anything about it?
Hughie
I know you and A-Train were tight. You guys came up together.
What are you, a fucking fan?!
Hughie
Listen… Those two guys in there, they wanna kill you, okay? So you give me something, maybe I can–
What? Hold them off? 'Cause they hang on your every word. You're the big man around here.
Hughie
Okay, you don't wanna talk, don't talk. I tried. Good luck.
[As Hughie is about to leave the room, Translucent stops him]
Buddy, my superpower ain't invisibility. [pause; makes himself visible] You know that, right? It's reading people. Watching them when they think they're alone. I see people for who they really are. I see you too, pal.
Hughie
Right. [kneels down to eye level with Translucent] 'Cause you know me so well, right?
Yeah. I know you're trying your damnedest to be tough. It's a little adorable, but the truth is… you're terrified. Shitting in your tightie-whities 'cause you're in over your head, fucked. And you know it. Hughie, I even kinda feel for you. Your girl died, and we do crazy shit when we got broken hearts. But now every instinct is screaming at you to head for the hills, and you should listen to that instinct.
Hughie
Unless we kill you first.
How? I got invulnerable skin. I'm a fucking superhero, guy. We fight gangs and terrorists. We save the world daily. I've stood in front of thousands of screaming fans, all of them creaming their jeans. …Who are you? A water balloon filled with blood and meat. Homelander's gonna find me, and when he does, he's gonna burst you wide open. I'm gonna make it home in time for cocktails. 'Cause that's who you are, and that's who I am. You're not the hero of this story, and I'm not the one who's trapped.
Hughie
[beat] Well, good luck. I tried.
Great chat. Run for the hills, Hughie.
[Butcher recruits his old partner, Mother's Milk, to the team. M.M. and Frenchie immediately tense up when they see each other]
MSMother's Milk
Motherfucker!
[They both approach each other with knives. Butcher gets in between them.]
Hughie
Butcher, who is this guy?!
You'll give the game away!
MSMother's Milk
Not until this frog gets what's coming.
The only thing that is coming is me on your mother's titties!
MSMother's Milk
Let me throw it at him, bitch!
MSMother's Milk
We had an agreement about him.
We agreed to put a pin in it, alright?
MSMother's Milk
There was no pin! I don't trust this French whore!
I am more American than you, you racist piece of shit!
Hughie
Why are they fighting?!
Nothing! It is water under the bridge!
MSMother's Milk
[to Frenchie] You tell that to Mallory's grandkids. Tell them it's water under the bridge.
Hughie
Who is Mallory?
Alright, the both of you, knock it on the head, now!
[The standoff is interrupted by a cell phone ringing]
MSMother's Milk
…Shit! [answers phone] Hey, Monique. How you doin', baby? Ooh, I forgot to marinade the tilapia. I am so sorry, sweetheart. [pause] Okay, how 'bout this? How about on my way home from work, I stop by DeLuca's, pick up two fat tenderloins, some portobello mushrooms, that pinot that you love so much. Yeah, baby. Okay, I–I gotta go. Alright, sweetheart. Yeah. Me, too. …Baby, I just–Uh, you're right. You're right. I love you, too. Okay. Bye.
[Mother's Milk makes kissing noises and hangs up. Frenchie and Butcher burst out laughing.]
MSMother's Milk
Fuck all of ya'll, okay?
Alright, alright. [to M.M. and Frenchie] Listen, you two knobbers kiss and make up, yeah? We got a fuckin' job to do.
MSMother's Milk
Who's this guy?
The new lad, Hughie. Hughie, Mother's Milk.
Hughie
That's a… nickname?
MSMother's Milk
[sarcastically] No, my mother actually named me "Mother's Milk".
Hughie
Did–Did she?
MSMother's Milk
So we got a French whore and a Stephen fucking Hawking. Great job, Butcher.
Well, it was Stephen fuckin' Hawking who dusted the Supe.
MSMother's Milk
So Translucent, huh? How the fuck did you pull that off?
Hughie
I don't know. Just lucky, I guess.
MSMother's Milk
Still… Must've been scary.
Hughie
You wanna know what's really messed up? It's, uh, in some ways just right in that moment, it felt kinda good.
MSMother's Milk
It's written all over your face, Hughie.
Hughie
What? How can you tell?
MSMother's Milk
'Cause I know how this job makes me feel.
Hughie
When I had that detonator in my hand, I felt like a–I felt like a rush.
MSMother's Milk
I get it.
Hughie
Like, I felt alive.
MSMother's Milk
But that rush, Hughie, is no different than the shit A-Train shoots up. Everything comes with a price.
Hughie
[beat] The last thing I ever said to Robin… was, "Don't you ever besmirch Billy Joel." That was the last thing that she heard before she burst into pieces. And I gotta live with that shit for the rest of my life. [pause] The price… Whatever it is, I'll pay it.
[Hughie and Annie sit down together after he finds out that she's Starlight]
Hughie
This is just so weird. I mean, the other day–Was it three days ago?
ASAnnie/Starlight
Mm-hmm.
Hughie
You just seemed like… You seemed so normal, you know? And now, it's just–
ASAnnie/Starlight
Now I'm a freak.
Hughie
No. No, not–No, that's not what I meant at all. I just meant–I just wasn't getting Beyoncé vibes, but… [Annie laughs] Not that you don't have that–
ASAnnie/Starlight
I'm messing with you.
Hughie
Okay.
ASAnnie/Starlight
You know… it was really nice to talk to someone who didn't know who I was. Once you're behind the scenes, it's… it's different.
Hughie
Like how?
ASAnnie/Starlight
I don't know if they really want you to be a hero. I think they just want you to look like one.
[Hughie turns off his radio so Butcher doesn't eavesdrop on their conversation]
Hughie
The other day on the bench when you were talking about how much you hated your job, you meant… you meant this job? [Annie nods] Then, um… Just quit. Just walk away. I mean, you got nothing to prove.
ASAnnie/Starlight
[beat] I should probably get back, you know, before they send a search party for me.
Hughie
Yeah, totally. Um, listen, Annie… Starlight? What do you, uh–
Hughie
This is insane, but uh–I know you're you and everything, but if you ever just wanted to, you know, get–
ASAnnie/Starlight
Would you like my number?
Hughie
[pause] Yeah. Yeah, that's–that's, uh… That's what I was asking.
Hughie
Do I call you, or do I just commit a crime?
ASAnnie/Starlight
Probably committing a crime would get me to you quicker.
[Butcher meets up with the rest of the Boys after Frenchie frees the Female from her armed captors. He inspects a Compound V needle that M.M. found]
So A-Train's runnin' it here, and these blokes are dosin' the Asian bird with it.
MSMother's Milk
Yeah, back when they had eyeballs.
Hughie
Yeah, but why? Is it a Vought thing or, like, a side hustle?
MSMother's Milk
[shows Butcher a paper bag] Came gift-wrapped in this.
Find out where it came from.
MSMother's Milk
I'll shake a few trees.
Why the hell were they dosin' her?
MSMother's Milk
[points at Frenchie] Why don't we ask Foie Gras over here? He's the one that let her out.
MSMother's Milk
Innocent? She's locked up in a cage underground with two armed guards?
I had a feeling about her.
MSMother's Milk
Nah, Frenchie. You just didn't follow the plan. You never follow the plan, man.
You need to unclench your asshole.
MSMother's Milk
You need to eat my clenched asshole.
Why are you two carryin' on like a bunch of fuckin' twats? We're sniffin' down a shit sandwich the size of Watergate. Vought and the Supes are both gonna be lookin' for her. All we gotta do is find the Female first.
[Butcher notices Hughie looking at his cell phone]
Keep lookin'. [to Hughie] Who's that, then, eh?
Hughie
It's nobody.
[Butcher gestures for Hughie to hand him his phone. He scrolls through Hughie's text messages.]
Hughie
Yeah, it's nothing. I mean, we were supposed to go on a date. Not a date. Just, she asked me if I wanted to ask her for her number, and then we just kinda platonically exchanged information, but the… the word "date" was never mentioned.
Call her back right now. You're fuckin' goin'.
Hughie
As a rule, I don't usually go out after a gory massacre.
Listen, here's the job. You're gonna hot mic her phone. From now on, we hear everything she says. I mean, this is a golden opportunity. And after all you done, piece of cake.
Hughie
Yeah, she's not a… She's not a bad person.
She's a Supe, Hughie. Just like the fuckin' rest of them.
Hughie
$15,000 for an exclusive VIP experience with Ezekiel. Seriously? There's not an easier, cheaper way for us to get to him?
We ain't gettin' to Ezekiel. You are.
Hughie
I am?
MSMother's Milk
Whoa, wait. What?
Well, Starlight's one of the headliners, right? She'll get you in.
Hughie
Whoa. Look, we've only been on, like, a date and a half, okay? I can't just ask her for a diamond club pass.
[takes off sunglasses] What's the matter? You worried your fake Supe girlfriend's gonna think you're usin' her?
Hughie
Okay, then what? I just go up to Ezekiel, "Hey, man. What's up with you smuggling blue dope into Chinatown basements?"
Yeah, pretty much. Once you show him this.
[Butcher shows Hughie a video of Ezekiel making out with two men at the Supe nightclub]
Hughie
Jesus. [pause] This is from that club you took me to?
You remembered our first night together. I'm touched.
MSMother's Milk
Okay, why is this the first time I'm hearing about this plan? This kid needs to be trained up, Butcher.
Hughie
Yeah. Yeah, what he said. I–I don't know how to blackmail anybody.
Hughie, you've done a murder. Comparatively speakin', this'll be a piece of cake.
PPastor
I'm–I'm not really sure what you're saying, son.
I'm sayin' that if there is some geezer up there with a big white beard, he's a world heavyweight cunt.
PPastor
I–I'm sorry, did you just call God a c-word?
Yeah. He's got a hard-on for mass murder and givin' kids cancer, and his big 'ol answer to the existential clusterfuck that is humanity is to nail his own bleedin' son to a plank. That is a cunt move. Come on, even you gotta agree with me here.
MSMother's Milk
Hey, hey, hey. Please…
We should lob a fuckin' nuke at him, get it over and done with. Y'know what I'm saying?
MSMother's Milk
[to the pastor] We're sorry, sir. We apologize. [to Butcher] My man…
Alright. Good talk. Think about it. I'm here all day, alright?
[Butcher and Mother's Milk walk away to a less populated area]
MSMother's Milk
You mind pipin' it down just a little bit, huh?
Oh, I'm sorry. Didn't mean to offend your inner black Baptist mum shoutin', "Praise the Lord."
MSMother's Milk
Fuck you. I'm Episcopalian. And there's nothing wrong with havin' a little church up in you, you know?
Said the bishop to the nun. What about you, Hughie? D'you believe in God?
Hughie
I mean, I don't know.
Hughie
Yeah, I don't know. I don't think it's Morgan Freeman up there or anything, but it can't all be random chaos.