[while in arraignment]
JPJudge Petrovsky
Mr. Newvine, how does your client plead?
JPJudge Petrovsky
Just an overworked judge, Mr. Varney. And I ask the questions. Not you. Guilty or not guilty?
How can you judge me if you're not God?
JPJudge Petrovsky
Mr. Newvine, control your client.
NNewvine
We plead not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect, your honor. [to his client] Daniel, please!
JPJudge Petrovsky
Miss Cabot?
Remand, your honor. The defendant is clearly a dangerous...
NO!!! [he punches Newvine; the court officers restrain him] YOU CAN'T JUDGE ME! You don't sit in judgment of me! You don't sit in judgment of me! YOU DON'T SIT IN JUDGMENT OF ME! You can't judge me! You can't judge me!
[Alex finds Judge Petrovsky coming out of an elevator]
JPJudge Petrovsky
Stalking me, counselor?
JPJudge Petrovsky
What are we searching for?
Videotapes of Roy Barnett engaged in sex acts with minors.
JPJudge Petrovsky
You're kidding! Where are they?
JPJudge Petrovsky
[scoffs] His mother would rather see you dead than let you search the place. Information from a reliable source? Don't start.
He was a victim of Roy Barnett's until 5 years ago.
JPJudge Petrovsky
Which is old news. What's the rest of the story?
He's in Sing Sing for aggravated sexual abuse-1 plus a separate fraud conviction.
JPJudge Petrovsky
I can't believe you're even asking!
Roy Barnett is a serial child molester. He will not stop.
JPJudge Petrovsky
Neither of which is a reason to grant a warrant.
JPJudge Petrovsky
You have no idea whether they even exist.
This is our last chance. I have to risk it.
JPJudge Petrovsky
I won't order a search based on the dubious word of a convicted pedophile! You look like Hell, Alexandra. Get some sleep.
Linda Cavanaugh never consented to any search! The Assistant District Attorney lied her way in by claiming the apartment was a crime scene.
Sam Cavanaugh's alleged suicide attempt was never investigated.
JPJudge Petrovsky
Miss Cabot, you're not going to sell that here. Don't even try it.
This was a blatant 4th Amendment violation, sanctioned and indeed carried out by the People. Therefore, any evidence found must be suppressed.
Mr. Barnett's 4th Amendment rights were not violated. Linda Cavanaugh's certainly were, but she isn't the defendant. Mr. Barnett is. He has no standing to contest a search of someone else's home.
Are you actually arguing that you can march in like the Gestapo and search any private residence?!
I'm arguing I can search any private residence that doesn't belong to your client, and it will have no bearing on these proceedings.
JPJudge Petrovsky
While I deplore the Assistant District Attorney's actions, I am forced to agree that the illegal search of Linda Cavanaugh's residence is a civil tort. The defendant's privacy was not violated, and therefore, he has no legal standing to contest the search. Motion to suppress the evidence is denied. Miss Cabot, I scarcely know where to begin. The liberties you have taken. The disdain you have shown toward the law in this court are highly unethical and a disgrace to your position. Be assured I will recommend your office to look into your actions. And you have done yourself a real disservice in my courtroom. I won't forget it.
The People have requested remand.
JPJudge Petrovsky
Well, you're not gonna get it. 300,000.
JPJudge Petrovsky
Overruled.
Your honor, I must object. Since you've rebuked me from manipulating the law to my own advantage, your ruling seems hypocritical.
JPJudge Petrovsky
That's enough. One more word out of you, and you'll be enjoying my hospitality.
Ma'am, I urge you to reconsider, or you will force me to file a grievance.
JPJudge Petrovsky
You're in contempt. Bailiff!
[the ADA leaves the courtroom]
JPJudge Petrovsky
Dr. Lang, you are out of order!
LDr. Lang
This entire trial is out of order! Don't you understand, I'm trying to save you! I'm trying to save the human race.
JPJudge Petrovsky
Sit down, or I will have you removed.
LDr. Lang
The cat's out of the bag, folks!
JPJudge Petrovsky
Bailiffs, remove the defendant.
LDr. Lang
[as he's escorted out] Science and the future wait for no one. If not me, someone will clone a human being. You wait and see!
JTJudge Terhune
[opens his door to find Novak standing outside] What the hell do you want?
I'm so sorry to bother you at home, Judge Terhune, but it's urgent.
JTJudge Terhune
Well, I'm in the middle of something pretty important myself.
MSMan's voice
[from inside] Joe! Are you foldin' this hand?
JTJudge Terhune
No! [to Novak] Look. C'mon. C'mon. C'mon in. C'mon.
[Novak follows him inside]
I just need your Honor's signature.
You just hit the jackpot, dearie.
[Novak stops at the door of a room; inside there are several judges playing poker]
JTJudge Terhune
[sits down at the table] I'm in. I believe you all know ADA Novak.
Judge Ridenour, Judge Petrovsky, Judge Wyler, Judge Bradley. I've had this nightmare before, only I was naked.
[Novak is attempting to prove that Katie can sworn-in at a trial]
Your honor, I submit that this witness can be sworn.
JPJudge Petrovsky
So ordered. [bangs gavel]
KKatie
[puts her hands over her ears in pain] Don't do that!
She has very sensitive hearing.
JPJudge Petrovsky
I... I'm sorry.
KKatie
That's okay. Can I have a hug?
JPJudge Petrovsky
[awkwardly] No. Maybe later.
CClerk
Docket ending 25801. People vs. James and Victoria Grall. One count assault in the second degree, one count grand larceny, one count burglary.
JPJudge Petrovsky
How do you plead?
JJames
Not guilty, your honor.
EEva
They should be charged with murder!
JPJudge Petrovsky
Court officers, remove this woman!
[the court officers escort Eva out of the courtroom as James and Victoria look on with remorse]
JJames
She's right. We should be charged with murder.
JPJudge Petrovsky
Would the People like to amend the charge?
No, your honor. The defendants are only grandstanding to further their political agenda.
JJames
If you were fit for your job, you'd seek justice for these lost souls.
VVictoria
It was an accident.
JPJudge Petrovsky
Mr. Hunter, control your clients.
As your honor well knows, according to New York law, life does not begin until a baby draws breath.
JJames
It begins at the moment of conception.
Even in the cases of abandoned newborns, a murder charge cannot be brought if it's determined the infant was stillborn.
JPJudge Petrovsky
The charges stand.
Actually, your honor, the grand larceny should be dropped to petty larceny. Human bodies cannot legally be sold, and therefore have no monetary value.
The couples who went to Hudson Cryobank each spent tens of thousands of dollars to get those embryos.
That was for services provided. It wasn't a sticker price of an embryo.
JPJudge Petrovsky
That's an issue for your trial judge. I'll add on the lesser charge and hear the People as to bail.
Excessive. The defendants are not a flight risk. They have ties to the community.
JPJudge Petrovsky
Bail is set at 10,000 each, cash or bond. [bangs gavel] Next case.