It's Trinity. He's back. He killed again.
Dexter
He... What?
Two people. Family members, his wife, Sally Mitchell, and his daughter Rebecca. Witpro placed the Mitchells in the middle of Bumfuck, Nebraska, and somehow Trinity managed to track them down.
Well, not Trinity. You killed Trinity.
Dexter
What about his son, Jonah?
Trinity came after him, too, but Jonah survived the attack.
Dexter
Didn't he say what happen?
According to his statement, Jonah came home from work and saw Trinity push Sally down the stairs and begin to beat her. Jonah fought him off. Trinity ran. And Jonah went upstairs and found Rebecca dead in a tub.
Or Jonah killed them and is masquerading as the Trinity Killer.
Dexter
And this all happened in Nebraska?
Some town called Kearney.
Brother Sam's death is hard enough on you, I'm sure, and to top it off with this...
Dexter
I... I'm gonna need some time.
Whatever you need. Take the day.
After Rita Morgan died, Kyle Butler's face was all over the news as her grieving husband. That's when we realized Kyle Butler was actually Dexter Morgan.
Dexter
No one connected the dots for the FBI.
We talked about it, but decided as a family you tried to help us. So we tried to help you.
Get the fuck out of my house.
Dexter
Show me where it happened, Jonah. Your father killed your mother here, on this staircase?
Police can be here in three minutes.
Dexter
Here is where her body was, and here is where you cleaned up your mother's blood.
You're a sick fuck, you know that?
Dexter
Where'd you fight your father off? It was here, right? When you took the weapon from him and hit him - chasing him off?
Dexter
Swinging at him the whole time.
Dexter
If that were true, there'd be blood on the wall, and on the ceiling here. But there's no spatter here.
Hey, that's because I cleaned it up. Now go!
Dexter
With bleach?
Dexter
Not on this wall - because there was no blood on this wall, because your father was never here. I know for a fact that Trinity did not kill anyone in this house.
Is that because you killed him?
Dexter
Yes - just like you killed your mother and your sister.
LLouis
So, the game is about homicide. And I know there's, like, a million video games out there about that. But the secret to this game is, and I haven't even told Jamie this yet, but in my game, you can be the serial killer.
Dexter
What?
LLouis
See, you have these character choices. You can be Dahmer, Jack the Ripper, the Bay Harbour Butcher.
Dexter
[Voiceover: I am the Bay Harbour Butcher.]
Dexter
This is the way the world ends. Your world, anyway...
No! No, no! I'm supposed to finish enacting the seven keys.
Dexter
Sorry.
But I was chosen! I was chosen to bring about the new world.
Dexter
Chosen to kill innocent people?
Dexter
My son is. You tried to kill him.
God allowed his son to die.
Dexter
How could you believe in that?
Because I walk the path of the righteous.
Dexter
I've known people who believed in God. They would never use their faith as a convenient excuse to kill 10 people. You used God. It's not the other way around.
You... You are a shining example of how putrid man has become.
Dexter
I am a father, a son, a serial killer.
You're going to burn in hell.
Dexter
No, I think I belong right here. Because maybe there is a place for me in this world - just as I am. Light cannot exist without darkness. Each has its purpose. And if there is a purpose to my darkness, maybe it's to bring some...balance to this world. Because, let's face it, the world is going to be a better place without you.
The world is going to end. And when it does, I will be by God's side.
Dexter
You sure?
Dexter
Good for you.
Dexter
No, I almost envy you. It must be nice to be so certain.
You're wrong about everything because you don't believe in God, but I have faith. I trust in God's plan.
Dexter
Really? Then it must be God's plan that you're on my table. Do you think it's God's will that I'm about to kill you? God has nothing to do with this! You are wrapped in plastic because I want to kill you.
This is not how it's supposed to be!
Dexter
Maybe this is exactly how it's supposed to be. Maybe everything is exactly as it should be.
I had this weird flashback of being on Rudy's table...Brian's tab...whatever the fuck you wanna call him - your brother's table.
Dexter
Sorry, that must have felt...not good for you.
It didn't. But what bothers me is that I was set up on that table the same way Travis Marshall was set up on the altar.
Dexter
Deb...
I mean how do you explain that?