Scenes with Ellie 11
[Joel enters Ellie's room to find her sitting by the window, reading a 20-year old diary from the previous occupant]
Ellie
Is this really all they had to worry about? Boys... movies... deciding which shirt goes with which skirt? It's bizarre.
Ellie
Why are you here?
I came here to talk to you.
Ellie
No, why are you still here? If you're gonna ditch me, ditch me.
What exactly did you hear?
Ellie
"I have to leave her, you have to take her." You know, I stood up for you today, because I thought... [she trails off]
I made this decision for your own good. You'll be way better off with Tommy. He knows the area better than I do -
Ellie
[Stands up] Do you give a shit about me or not!?
Ellie
Then what are you so afraid of? [long beat] I'm not her, you know. [another long beat, as Joel processes what she said] Maria told me about Sarah, and I -
[interrupting, in a quiet, angry tone] Don't. Don't say another word.
Ellie
[approaching him] I'm sorry about your daughter, Joel. But I have lost people too.
You have no idea what loss is.
Ellie
Everybody I have cared for has either died, or left me... [shoves him hard, her voice rising to a shout] Everybody, fucking except for you! So don't tell me I'd be safe with somebody else, because the truth is I'd just be more scared!
[beat]
You're right. You're not my daughter. And I sure as hell ain't your dad. Now come dawn, we're going our separate ways.
[Ellie and Riley are attempting to cope with having been bitten. Riley has her gun by her side.]
Ellie
What are we gonna do?
RRiley
The way I see it, we've got two options. One: We take the easy way out. It's quick, painless... No. No, I don't like Option One. Option Two: We just keep going.
Ellie
What are you talking about, Riley? It's over.
RRiley
It will be. But not yet. It ends this way for everyone sooner or later, right? Some of us just... get there faster than others. But we don't quit. Whether... it's two minutes, or two days... we don't give that up. I don't wanna give that up. We can just be all poetic and shit and lose our minds together.
Ellie
...what's Option Three?
RRiley
I'm sorry. I'm sorry.
DDavid
You know, you really shouldn't be out here all on your own.
Ellie
From where I'm sitting, you shouldn't be out here on your own.
DDavid
Fair enough. So what's your name?
[Ellie stays silent.]
DDavid
It's hard to trust strangers, I know -- but I honestly mean you no harm. And for what it's worth? There's room for you in our group, if you want.
Ellie
You inviting me to your hunger club? Thanks.
DDavid
It's true, we're hungry. But... we're still here. I'm a decent man, just trying to take care of the people who rely on me.
Ellie
You're their leader?
DDavid
Wasn't my choice; it was theirs, but... yes.
Ellie
They chose to follow you. Is this some weird cult thing?
DDavid
Uh... Well, you sorta kinda got me there, I am a preacher. But just pretty standard Bible stuff. [off Ellie's look] What?
Ellie
The whole world ended and you still believe that shit.
DDavid
I actually started believing after the world ended. Before that, I was a teacher -- Math. Taught kids about your age.
Ellie
So you went from teacher to preacher because, what, it fucking rhymes?
Ellie
But seriously...
DDavid
Well, I found God after the apocalypse, which is either the best time or the worst time to find Him. Hard to say. But when the Pittsburgh QZ fell in '17, Fireflies and FEDRA... I left with a few others and that's how I ended up with our flock.
Ellie
You're a long way from Pittsburgh.
DDavid
Yep, we'd settle somewhere and then raiders would come, so we'd move again. And as we wandered, we picked up new people along the way until... we ended up here.
Ellie
Well, your luck had to run out sooner or later.
DDavid
Hm? "Luck"? There's no such thing as luck. No, I... I believe everything happens for a reason. [off Ellie's more incredulous look] It does! It does, I can prove it to you.
Ellie
Okay.
DDavid
We didn't expect this winter to be so cruel; nothing'll grow, grain's been hard to find... So I sent four of our people to a nearby town to, to scavenge what they could. And only three of 'em came back. And the one that didn't was a father; he had a daughter just like you, and her dad was taken from her. Turns out, he was murdered by this crazy man -- and get this... That crazy man was travelling with a little girl.
[Ellie shifts.]
DDavid
You see? Everything happens for a reason.
[Ellie is locked in a cell with David, whom she has just discovered is a cannibal. She regards a bowl of mystery meat suspiciously.]
DDavid
For what it's worth, this is just deer meat, I swear.
Ellie
You're gonna chop me up into little pieces.
DDavid
I'd rather not. Please, just tell me your name.
[Ellie glares daggers into him.]
DDavid
If you wanna judge me...
Ellie
Judge you?! You're eating people, you sick fuck!
[She kicks the bowl away.]
DDavid
...Yes. There are only a few of us that know, but I would've told you. Sooner or later. I guess "sooner".
Ellie
You're an animal.
DDavid
Well, yes, we all are. That's sort of the point. It was a last resort, you think it doesn't shame me? But what was I supposed to do? Let them starve, these people who put their lives in my hands? Who e-- expect me to keep them safe? Who love me?
Ellie
Yeah, maybe!
DDavid
You don't believe that. I don't think your friend would, either. Didn't he take another man's life to save yours?
Ellie
He was defending himself.
DDavid
He was defending you. But you knew that. You see a lot. So do I. And you know what I see when I look at you? Me. You remind me of me. You're a natural leader, you're smart, loyal... violent.
Ellie
You don't know anything about me.
DDavid
But I do. If I let you out of that cage right now? Put that knife of yours in your hand? You'd stick me in a second. You have a violent heart, and I should know. I've always had a violent heart. And I struggled with it for a long time, but then the world ended and I was shown the truth.
Ellie
Right. By God.
DDavid
No. By Cordyceps. What does Cordyceps do, is it evil? No! It's fruitful, it multiplies; it feeds and protects its children, and it secures its future with violence if it must. And they would follow us... Lord knows I could use the help. Look what's happened. Think of what we could do together, as strong as we are? We'd make this place perfect. We'd grow, spread out, and we'd do whatever we needed for our people. [he approaches the cage, covering Ellie's with his own] Imagine the life we could give them. Imagine the life we could build.
Ellie
Oh.
[Ellie takes the bait... Then breaks his finger. Tries taking his keys. He punches her, walks towards the door.]
DDavid
You little cunt. Let's see what I go tell the others now.
Ellie
Ellie...
Ellie
Tell them that Ellie is the little girl who broke your FUCKING FINGER!
DDavid
How did you put it, hm? "Tiny little pieces"?
[Joel and Ellie enter an abandoned medical facility]
Ellie
Is this a FEDRA thing?
No. Army. They put these places up all around. First few days after the outbreak. Emergency medical camps. Obviously didn't last. They had me in one just like this.
Ellie
With Sarah?
No, she was gone already.
Ellie
Oh. So what was wrong with you?
[points to the scar on his head] It was for this.
Ellie
Ah, the guy who shot and missed? I figure that would've happened later.
Ellie
Well, I gotta hand it to the army people, they were way better at stitching you up than I was...
It was me. [Ellie turns to look back at him] I was the guy who shot and missed.
[Ellie looks horrified. Joel takes the rifle off his back and perches on a concrete barrier. Ellie comes and sits beside him]
There's no story. Sarah died, and I couldn't see the point anymore. Simple as that. And I wasn't scared either. I was ready. I couldn't have been more ready. And when I... when I... [motions] went to pull the trigger, I flinched. Still don't know why. Anyway, the reason I'm telling you all this is -
Ellie
I know why you're telling me all this.
[beat]
Ellie
So time heals all wounds, I guess?
[turns to look at her] It wasn't time that did it.
[Ellie looks at him, stunned, as she realises what he meant]
Ellie
[tearfully] I'm glad that... that didn't work out.
Ellie
We should probably get going.
[Ellie and Jesse are walking through the town on their way to their patrol, and Ellie notices all the preparations going on]
Ellie
What's everyone doing?
JJesse
Council put the entire town on alert. Last night, Kylie and Max found a pile of dead infected near Seven Cabins. Frozen stiff.
Ellie
Okay?
JJesse
They didn't think anything of it, until 30 live ones broke through from underneath the corpses. They're using their own dead like insulation.
Ellie
Thirty? Fuck. They okay?
JJesse
Yeah. Sprinted back on their horses. Sent a squad out to clear the infected, but now we're thinking we don't know how many are underneath the snow. Could be 30 more. Could be a thousand more.
Ellie
A thousand? Get the fuck outta here.
JJesse
[chuckling] Ah yes, certainty masquerading as knowledge. It's very Ellie of you.
Ellie
Suck my dick.
JJesse
Also, somebody told the council a ghost story about the world's smartest infected, and now everybody's spooked out of their minds.
Ellie
[irritated] It wasn't a ghost story. You know, no offence man, I'm gonna do my patrol with Joel.
JJesse
Umm... yes, offence, 'cuz that's the one person you've been avoiding like the plague.
Ellie
Well, we're better now, okay?
JJesse
As of when? Cuz last night-
Ellie
[shouting] Yeah, I know what happened last night. Can you shut the fu... [catches herself and calms down] My shit with Joel is complicated. I know that. From the outside, it probably looks really bad. It has been really bad. But I'm still me, and he's still Joel, and we... And nothing's ever gonna change that, ever. So you can all stop talking about us, worrying about us, and thinking about us, alright?
JJesse
So you two hashed it out? [Ellie gives him a look that says "what did I just say?"] Uh... alright.
[At the Jackson Hole council meeting]
RRachel
I said that Joel meant so much to so many of us. But he wasn't the only one. I lost my sister that day. A lot of people in here buried family. And now you wanna send, what, you're saying 16 of our best? Well, while they're gone, who's gonna be on the wall if Raiders come? A wall that's barely mended. And none of you up there can promise us that all 16 will come back. So, my heart is with you, Tommy, and Ellie. But we are too hurt, and it is too soon.
MMaria
Thank you, Rachel. [she gets down from her chair] Next is Carlisle.
[Carlisle gets up and clears his throat].
CCarlisle
I'll be quick, cuz this one's simple to me. People came and killed Joel. So why wouldn't we wanna take our vengeance? Well, because we're not supposed to. Forgive, and be forgiven. No grudges, no revenge. And I'm not even a Christian. I've always seen wisdom in that. That's what separates us from the Raiders and the murderers. Our capacity for mercy.
SSeth
Those sons of bitches don't deserve our mercy.
[Ellie looks at him, surprised that he of all people would speak up in Joel's favour]
CCarlisle
Well, of course they don't deserve it. That's what makes it mercy.
SSeth
Well, to hell with that! [rising] And to hell with you for saying it, Carlisle!"
MMaria
You're not on the list!
SSeth
[shouting] No! What the hell are we all talking about, here? Boo-hoo, it's not fair. What, we gotta forgive everybody when they show up and piss in our eye? They came into our house! They took one of ours! My God, somebody shoots your brother, you wanna take the locks off your doors!? Grow up! You idiots, they'll come back. They'll come back because we didn't make 'em pay! And when they come back, they'll be laughing! And you'll all deserve it. Bunch of... goddamn victims. [He sits down].
[Maria crosses Carlisle's name off her list, leaving only Ellie].
Ellie
[gets to her feet, takes a piece of paper and begins to read] I normally don't write things down, because I normally don't think before I talk. Which has gotten me in trouble before, a lot. And it's cost me in ways that sometimes couldn't be undone. But I can't afford that right now, because I know what I'm asking is a lot. I'm asking us to risk more people and resources, and at the worst possible time. And I want everyone to know it's not because I want revenge. It's not. It's not about revenge. [looking directly at Maria] What I want is what you used to give people. I want justice. Because it's either that, or we do nothing. That's what everyone else out there is going to do for us. Nothing. A whole world of people who won't lift a finger if something bad happens to me or you. We have a word for these people. They're called strangers. Well, I don't think we're strangers to each other. And I wanna know that I can count on you. And I swear, if anyone hurts any of you, or the people you love, you can count on me. [Gail smiles, unconvinced] That's what holds all this together. Not potluck dinners or New Year's Eve dances. Definitely not a wall, because that thing got busted through. But Jackson is still here! I'll accept whatever the council decides. But I am asking you, please... Do what it takes to see that justice is done. Not for me. Not even for Joel. I am asking you, please, do it for us.
[Ellie and Dina are snuggling together after having sex for the first time]
Ellie
Why now?
DDina
I thought you were gone. And then all of a sudden, this future I was imagining... wasn't gonna happen. Where we're together, and we have a kid, and... I don't even know if you want that.
Ellie
I want it with you.
DDina
I'm sorry it took so long. I knew how you felt about me.
Ellie
[surprised] How? I was hiding it really well.
DDina
[laughing] No, you kind of fucking weren't. I'm sorry! I wanted to.
Ellie
Yeah?
DDina
When I was little, I told my mother I liked boys, and I liked girls. And she said, "No, you like boys." And it just... I got... stuck. Even after she died, it... I tried to make things work with Jesse, because I like him. I do, I think he's a really good guy. But he wasn't the one. Still kept trying anyway. Couldn't let myself just... be.
Ellie
You were scared.
DDina
Not everyone's as brave as you.
Ellie
I'm not brave. I'm just obvious.
[In the spore-filled basement of the hospital, Ellie finds Nora struggling for air. She advances on her, with her pistol raised].
NNora
[coughing] You stupid bitch. Spores! We're breathing spores. We're infected. You killed us both.
Ellie
Did I?
[Nora looks up at Ellie, and after a moment, the truth dawns on her]
NNora
You're... you're her. The immune girl. You're... You're real.
Ellie
Yeah. Where's Abby?
NNora
Don't you know what he did?
Ellie
I don't care.
NNora
[indignant] You don't care? He killed... everyone in that hospital. Including the only fucking person alive that could make a cure from you. That was Abby's father. And Joel... Joel shot him in the head. That's what he did.
Ellie
I know.
[Caught off guard, Nora scoffs, and continues wheezing. Ellie holsters her gun, and crouches down before her]
Ellie
Where's Abby?
NNora
[coughing, and slumping back to the floor] No.
[Ellie turns around and sees some piping on the wall behind her. She picks up an L-shaped one and advances on Nora]
Ellie
Where is she?
[Ellie violently strikes her with the pipe, causing her to scream in pain]
Ellie
Where is she?
[Ellie strikes her again]
Ellie
WHERE IS SHE!?
[Ellie's last conversation with Joel - after seemingly walking past him on his porch the night before his death, she doubles back and returns to him. He places the guitar down and gets up, picking up his mug and sipping it as he comes to stand next to her.]
Ellie
What are you drinking?
Ellie
Where'd you get it?
Um... The people that came through last week. I'm a little embarrassed for what I traded to get it, but it's not bad.
[Long pause]
Ellie
[referring to their earlier confrontation] I had Seth under control.
Ellie
And I don't wanna ever hear about you taking me off patrol again.
Okay. [Another long pause] So, Dina... Is she your girlfriend now?
Ellie
No. No, she... It was just one kiss. Didn't mean anything. I don't know why she did that.
Ellie
[sighs. To herself] I'm so stupid.
Look, I don't know what Dina's intentions are, but... well, she'd be lucky to have you.
Ellie
[turning to look at him, her tone now more confrontational] You're such an asshole. You lied to me. You looked me in the eyes, and you lied, and it was the same face. The same fucking look. But I think I knew already. I knew this whole time. So, I'm gonna give you one last chance. Tell me what happened with the Fireflies. If you lie to me again, we're done. [His face crumpling, Joel nods] Were there other immune people? [Joel takes a moment, but finally shakes his head] Were there raiders? [he shakes his head again] Could they have made a cure? [Joel visibly struggles, but finally nods. Ellie, shattered, begins to cry herself] Did you...? [Without needing her to finish, Joel nods again] And Marlene? [He nods again, and Ellie begins to breathe heavily as the emotion overwhelms her]
Makin' a cure... would've killed you.
Ellie
Then I was supposed to die! That was my purpose! My life would've fucking mattered! But you took that from me! You took it from everyone.
Yes. And I'll pay the price... because you're gonna turn away from me. But if somehow, I had a second chance at that moment... I would do it all over again.
Ellie
[bitterly] Because you're selfish.
[in a choked voice] Because I love you. In a way you... you can't understand. Maybe you never will. But if that day should come... If you should ever have one of your own... well, then... I hope you do a little better than me.
Ellie
[takes a deep breath] I don't think I can forgive you for this. But I would like to try.
[As Jesse and Ellie, looking for Tommy, reach an exposed side of the building they are in, Ellie spots something in the distance. At the same time, there is the sound of gunfire]
JJesse
You hear that? It's in the right direction.
[Ellie looks through her binoculars and sees a large ferris wheel, and the Seattle Aquarium]
JJesse
[concurrently] I don't see an easy way north, but if he got there, it means we can too. [when Ellie doesn't respond] Ellie?
Ellie
[whispering] The wheel. The whale.
Ellie
She's in the fucking aquarium!
Ellie
Abby! The one who killed Joel, she's in the aquarium! [Jesse looks at her in disbelief] It's too far to swim, we need a boat-
JJesse
What are you talking about!?
Ellie
What?
JJesse
[points] Ellie, Tommy's over there. That's where we're goin'.
Ellie
You don't know that's him.
Ellie
We don't, and even if it is, he's got them pinned down.
JJesse
For now. They called for backup!
Ellie
Then he'll pin more of them down. I know him! He would want me to do this! Jesus Christ, if three more people had voted with you, you'd be coming with me!
JJesse
[pause] I voted 'No'.
Ellie
[stunned, and enraged] Why?
JJesse
Because everything you do, you do for you.
Ellie
Oh my God.
Ellie
Oh my God.
JJesse
Ellie! It wasn't the best interests of the community...
Ellie
[exploding] FUCK THE COMMUNITY! All you do is talk about the fucking community, you hypocrite! You think you're good, and I'm bad? You let a kid die today, Jesse, because why? He wasn't in your community? [Advancing on him] Let me tell you about my community. My community was beaten to death in front of me while I was forced to fucking watch! So don't look at me like you're better than me, or like you'd do anything differently if you were in my shoes, because you're not, and you wouldn't.
JJesse
[angry, but resigned] I really hope you make it.
[He turns and walks away]