Alfred Pennyworth and Bruce Wayne in “The Butler Did It”

After stealing from you twice and having a punch-up with the Batman, I should hope you'd have my head examined.

Everything appears normal, Alfred.

Then you and I were simply victims of hypnosis?

Not "we". When the Batwave sounded, it jarred you and the other butlers from your trance. But my hallucinations continued. Hallucinations so powerful, they could only be the work of a Spellbinder.

A Spellbinder, sir?

During my studies in the Far East, I learned of a remote temple whose monks performed a particularly intense form of meditation, believed to lead to that which only few could achieve: the mystic power of the third eye. A state of awareness so pure or potent, one could project one's visions into reality.

So our three-eyed scoundrel possesses an enlightened mind and a corrupted soul.

If last night was only a rehearsal, I believe he's after a fourth eye.

The Sarkana gemstone?

And since Spellbinder somehow managed to implant you and the butlers with hypnotic suggestions, he'll no doubt trigger you three to steal it for him.

Me, steal from charity?! You must lock me up at once!