Masha, Gus and Willow and others in “Unfinished Business”

I hope you're all prepared for a truly scary ride.

[chanting] Make us cry! Make us cry!

Because there's nothing scarier than knowledge.

Gus

Boo, just lie to me!

Let me tell you the eeriest unsolved mystery of Gravesfield: the Tale of the Brothers Wittebane.

Amity

[to Luz and Hunter] Wittebane? Isn't that Belos?

The year is 1613. Two orphaned brothers arrive in Gravesfield. Their names? Philip...and Caleb.

Hunter

[experiencing flashbacks of Belos and himself] Oh, no...

Caleb did his best to take care of his younger brother. They tried to fit in with this town, and its unsavoury practices. They became witch-hunters! Local lore suggests that the Brothers Wittebane met a real witch from another world - her name was Evelyn! And the older brother was spirited away. She dazzled him with magic and visions of a strange yet beautiful place! They used a secret code to travel between worlds. Philip set off to save his brother and bring the witch to justice - but neither were ever seen again! Maybe Philip saved Caleb, and they went on to lead peaceful lives. Or maybe he's still chasing his brother, [shining their flashlight under their face] caught in a cycle of horror and strife! [turns off the flashlight, casually] Sounds like big bro got a hot witch girlfriend and little bro got upset. But that's just me.